BEFORE TILL archival sealBefore TillThe Living Evidence Archive

Research object · BT-CLM-00279

Was Alma Smith Carthan a daughter of George Smith?

Under Investigation· 1 sourceNot yet reviewed
Research & Interpretation byAmberly R. Carter-Mills— Founder, Creator & Descendant Archivist

The Claim

Parent-child relationship between george-smith and alma-smith-carthan, held as a single generation link rather than as part of a lineage assertion.

Public Summary

Family knowledge places Alma Carthan as a daughter of George Smith. The archive holds no contemporary record for this link, so the generation is carried as under verification.

Evidence Reviewed

  • Partially SupportsWeak

    Family knowledge places Alma Carthan as a daughter of George Smith. The archive holds no contemporary record for this link, so the generation is carried as under verification.

    Source: Family knowledge supplied by Amberly R. Carter-Mills · BEFORE TILL research files

    Family knowledge and documentary verification are recorded separately. Both are shown; neither is presented as the other.

The Evidence Trail

Step 1 · Claim

Was Alma Smith Carthan a daughter of George Smith?

Under Investigation· 1 source

BT-CLM-00279

Parent-child relationship between george-smith and alma-smith-carthan, held as a single generation link rather than as part of a lineage assertion.

Step 2 · Evidence & Source

  1. Partially Supports · Weak weight

    Family knowledge places Alma Carthan as a daughter of George Smith. The archive holds no contemporary record for this link, so the generation is carried as under verification.

    Family knowledge supplied by Amberly R. Carter-Mills · BEFORE TILL research files · Authored Narrative

    BT-EVD-00281 ← BT-SRC-00264

    Researcher interpretation · Amberly R. Carter-Mills

    Family knowledge and documentary verification are recorded separately. Both are shown; neither is presented as the other.

Step 3 · Conclusion

Under InvestigationVersion 1 · Current · Low confidence

Researcher interpretation · Amberly R. Carter-Mills

Family knowledge places Alma Carthan as a daughter of George Smith. The archive holds no contemporary record for this link, so the generation is carried as under verification.

What is not known: No contemporary record establishing this relationship has been examined by this archive and entered as an original.

What could change this: Locate and examine a census enumeration, birth record, death record naming parents, marriage record, obituary, Social Security application, church record or probate file.

How the Evidence Sits Together

What supports the claim

Observations that carry the claim forward.

  • Family knowledge places Alma Carthan as a daughter of George Smith. The archive holds no contemporary record for this link, so the generation is carried as under verification.

    Partially Supports · Weak weight

    Family knowledge supplied by Amberly R. Carter-Mills

    Family knowledge and documentary verification are recorded separately. Both are shown; neither is presented as the other.

What complicates or contradicts it

Kept in view rather than discarded.

  • Nothing in this column for this claim.

What only provides context

Consistent, but not identifying or probative on its own.

  • Nothing in this column for this claim.

Research Conclusion

Under InvestigationVersion 1 · Current

Family knowledge places Alma Carthan as a daughter of George Smith. The archive holds no contemporary record for this link, so the generation is carried as under verification.

What is known: Family knowledge places Alma Carthan as a daughter of George Smith. The archive holds no contemporary record for this link, so the generation is carried as under verification.

What is not known: No contemporary record establishing this relationship has been examined by this archive and entered as an original.

Future research: Locate and examine a census enumeration, birth record, death record naming parents, marriage record, obituary, Social Security application, church record or probate file.

Amberly's Research Notes

No research note has been published for this claim yet.

From the research notebook ofAmberly R. Carter-Mills— Founder, Creator & Descendant Archivist

What We Still Need to Find

Was Alma Smith Carthan a daughter of George Smith?

Provenance, Access and Use

Source creator
Varies by record — see each source
Who made the original record.
Researcher of record
Amberly R. Carter-Mills — Founder, Creator & Descendant Archivist
Located, transcribed, weighed and interpreted the evidence.
Publishing archive
BEFORE TILL: The Living Evidence Archive
Holds the object, its identifiers and its revision history.

Family knowledge supplied by Amberly R. Carter-Mills

BT-SRC-00264
Evidentiary weight 3 of 4. Primary oral history — for the intervieweeOriginal image: Transcript verification pendingA first-person account, primary evidence for the speaker's own life. It is not evidence about another person unless that person is named in it.
Creator
Not recorded
Date created
Not recorded
Repository
BEFORE TILL research files
Collection
Not recorded
Record form
Authored Narrative
Source type
Oral History
Accessed
Not recorded

Access and use

No rights statement has been recorded for this source. Verify rights with the holding repository before republication.

BEFORE TILL publishes description, transcription and analysis. Reuse of the underlying record is governed by the holding repository. Cite this archive by its persistent identifier when quoting our reading of the record.

Submit a Lead

Do you hold a record, a photograph, or a family account bearing on this question? Submit it for review. A submission becomes a research lead; it does not change a published conclusion on its own.

Attach files (optional)

Scans, photographs, or a recorded account. Up to 5 files, 25.0 MB each — images, PDF, or audio. Attachments are stored privately and are never published without review.

Please do not send Social Security numbers, account or policy numbers, unredacted identification for living people, financial information, private medical records, or records about a living person who has not agreed to it. Everything you send is stored privately and reviewed before anything is published — nothing you submit appears on the site automatically. See the records and documents policy.